05 / MARKET INTEGRITY

Insider trading on prediction markets: evidence and cases

~$200m

What flagged trades and US case reporting actually establish, and why suspicious patterns must not be presented as proven offences.

The short reading

Some trading patterns have prompted serious reporting and legal scrutiny. The most important distinction is between a model flag, an allegation and a proved offence.

This is research and context, not a market recommendation or a statement of UK product availability.

The $200 million and 34,000 figures come from a Bloomberg News investigation, "Prediction Markets Are Minting a New Type of Insider Trader", published on 20 July 2026 (the date displayed on the retrieved article). Bloomberg reviewed Polymarket trades flagged by the analytics tool Polysights between August 2025 and June 2026. A flag is a screening signal. It is not a finding that anyone broke the law.

At a glance~$200mof flagged Polymarket trades reported for January–June 2026, not proven illicit tradesView original source
Measure / 0134,000flagged transactions reviewedBloomberg describes a broader flagged sample from August 2025 to June 2026.View original source
Measure / 0257%recently created walletsShare of the most profitable flagged wallets created within 24 hours of trading.View original source
Measure / 032026reported US criminal filingDOJ unsealed the Van Dyke indictment on 23 April; the October dismissal ruling is not a conviction.View original source
01 / Analysis

A flagged trade is not a verdict

Bloomberg examined transactions identified by Polysights as potentially linked to insider activity. It reports roughly $200m in flagged trades from January to June 2026 and a 34,000-trade review spanning a longer August 2025–June 2026 period. These are different denominators. A newly created wallet or well-timed profit is a reason to investigate, not proof of inside information.

02 / Analysis

The reported US criminal case

In United States v. Gannon Ken Van Dyke (S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cr-00156), DOJ unsealed an indictment on 23 April 2026 alleging misuse of classified military information to trade on Polymarket. Judge Margaret M. Garnett denied dismissal on 26 October 2026. That procedural ruling is not a conviction. In United States v. Michele Spagnuolo (1:26-cr-00278), DOJ announced charges against the Google engineer on 27 May 2026; later court records refer to an indictment. An October order sets oral argument on dismissal for 21 December 2026. Both remain pretrial in the court records reviewed on 5 November 2026. Defendants are presumed innocent unless proved guilty.

03 / Analysis

The legal question is product-specific

The US Congressional Research Service describes how existing laws may apply to prediction markets. The legal analysis depends on the contract, conduct and regulator. This page does not imply the same rule or charge would apply in Great Britain. The UK legal guide addresses the distinct regulator and operator questions for UK readers.

04 / Analysis

How to interpret a sudden move

A price jump before public news might reflect informed legitimate research, thin liquidity, a reporting leak, manipulation or chance. Look for documented evidence and the platform’s response rather than inferring guilt from a chart. Published market surveillance and dispute procedures matter more than rumours.

Record / Not a conviction count

Documented milestones.

  1. Flagged-trading review period

    Bloomberg reports roughly $200m in Polymarket trades flagged in this six-month period; a flag is not a finding of wrongdoing.

    Read the source
  2. United States v. Van Dyke

    DOJ unsealed the indictment; the CFTC separately filed its first event-contract insider-trading complaint.

    Read the source
  3. United States v. Spagnuolo

    DOJ announced criminal charges; the CFTC also brought a civil complaint. Charges are allegations.

    Read the source
  4. Van Dyke dismissal motion denied

    The prosecution continues; the court did not decide guilt.

    Read the source
  5. Spagnuolo hearing scheduled

    Oral argument on dismissal is set for 21 December 2026; no conviction is established by this order.

    Read the source

Only documented milestones from the cited material are shown; no additional cases are assumed.

The parallel civil cases are CFTC v. Van Dyke (1:26-cv-03369) and CFTC v. Spagnuolo (1:26-cv-04419). Court orders stayed them pending the respective criminal proceedings on 7 August and 30 September 2026. A stay is a pause, not a dismissal or finding of liability. Public court-document mirrors may lag the full docket; these are the records reviewed on 5 November 2026.

Method / How to read this

Methodology.

Bloomberg’s figures come from Polysights screening of Polymarket’s global venue, not a count of proven offences. DOJ and CFTC releases establish allegations and filing dates; subsequent court orders establish procedural developments, not guilt. CourtListener/RECAP and Midpage reproduce court records and may not contain every later filing. These US cases are not statements of UK law. The sources are not combined into a single incidence rate.

Reference / Original record

Sources.

  1. 01
    Prediction markets are minting a new type of insider trader
    Reporting

    Bloomberg News, 20 July 2026 (displayed byline)

    Funder: Bloomberg reporting using Polysights-flagged trades.

    Bloomberg News, 20 July 2026 (displayed byline). Flagged activity is a screening signal, not proof of insider trading. The reviewed trades concern Polymarket’s global exchange.

  2. 02
    Prediction Market’s First Insider Trading Case
    Reporting

    Funder: Forbes contributor reporting; confirm subsequent court developments from primary records.

    Reports a US federal criminal allegation filed in April 2026. An allegation is not a conviction.

  3. 03
    Congressional Research Service: insider trading and prediction markets
    Government & policy

    Funder: US Congressional Research Service.

    US policy analysis, not a statement of UK law or advice about any particular case.

  4. 04
    Why Prediction Markets Are a New Frontier for Insider Trading
    Reporting

    Bloomberg Law, 28 May 2026

    Funder: Bloomberg Law

    Bloomberg Law, 28 May 2026.

  5. 05
    DOJ: Gannon Ken Van Dyke indictment unsealed, 23 April 2026
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    United States v. Van Dyke, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cr-00156. Criminal allegations, not a conviction.

  6. 06
    CFTC: first event-contract insider-trading complaint, 23 April 2026
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    CFTC v. Van Dyke, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-03369. Civil complaint separate from the criminal prosecution.

  7. 07
    DOJ: Google employee Michele Spagnuolo charged, 27 May 2026
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    United States v. Spagnuolo, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cr-00278; initially charged by complaint. Allegations are not findings.

  8. 08
    CFTC: Google employee insider-trading complaint, 27 May 2026
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    CFTC v. Spagnuolo, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-04419. Civil allegations.

  9. 09
    United States v. Van Dyke: dismissal denied, 26 October 2026
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    Court opinion, document 47, hosted by CourtListener. Denial of dismissal is not a guilty verdict.

  10. 10
    United States v. Spagnuolo: December hearing set
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    26 October 2026 order sets oral argument for 21 December. Criminal proceedings remain pretrial in the records reviewed.

  11. 11
    CFTC v. Van Dyke: civil stay order, 7 August 2026
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    Court order reproduced by Midpage. Civil case stayed pending the criminal proceeding; not a dismissal.

  12. 12
    CFTC v. Spagnuolo: civil stay, 30 September 2026
    Government & policy

    Funder: US government or court record; CourtListener hosts copies of court documents where indicated.

    Court order, document 23, hosted by CourtListener. Stay lasts until completion of the criminal case.

Follow the original documents for definitions, scope and subsequent revisions. Browse the full source library ↗

Questions / In context

Questions worth asking

01Were $200m of trades proved illegal?

No. Bloomberg describes trades flagged as potentially suspicious by an analytics system; a flag is not a legal finding.

02Is a profitable new wallet evidence of insider trading?

It can be a signal for further examination, but timing and profit alone do not establish that someone used non-public information.

03Does US insider-trading law automatically apply in the UK?

No. Jurisdiction, product classification and the facts matter. This page is not legal advice.